Song review

We Believe

Matthew Hooper, Richie Fike, Travis Ryan

CCLI #7018338Key of D130 BPM4/4Hymn lineage: Apostles' Creed
9.3/10
Use freely

A musically energetic, creed-based corporate anthem that successfully translates historic Christian confession into modern congregational song. Theologically comprehensive and scripturally rooted, covering the Trinity, incarnation, crucifixion, resurrection, and eschaton with declarative clarity. The Apostles' Creed structure provides doctrinal weight that transcends stylistic preference. Minor singability concerns at the upper range and rapid lyric density at tempo are offset by strong congregational appeal and pastoral utility for teaching core doctrine.

Five lenses

01Scriptural fidelity
9.7
The creed-based structure ensures scriptural fidelity across all major theological movements, though not every phrase offers direct quotation

This song operates as a confessional hymn, drawing from the Apostles' Creed framework and grounding each article in biblical narrative. The declaration of belief in the Father as Creator echoes Genesis 1, the affirmation of Christ's virgin birth reflects Matthew 1 and Luke 1, the crucifixion and resurrection anchor in the Gospels and 1 Corinthians 15, and the second coming draws from Acts 1 and Revelation 19. The Holy Spirit's role in sanctification mirrors John 14-16 and Romans 8. The structure itself is a biblical-theological synthesis rather than verse-by-verse exegesis, which is appropriate for confessional worship.

02Theological clarity
9.8
One minor ambiguity in the phrase regarding sin's defeat could benefit from contextual preaching, but the overall arc is precise

The song functions as a sung catechism, moving systematically through the Trinity and the economy of salvation. It presents God as Creator, Christ as incarnate Redeemer who died, rose, and will return, and the Spirit as sanctifying presence. The theological arc is historic Christian orthodoxy: creation, fall (implied in the need for salvation), incarnation, atonement, resurrection, ascension, ongoing sanctification, and eschatological hope. The corporate 'we believe' voice reinforces that this is the church's faith, not individual opinion. No heterodox elements are present; every article aligns with Nicene-Chalcedonian orthodoxy and Baptist theological commitments.

03Congregational singability
8.4
The range pushes most congregations at the upper end, and the lyric density at 130 BPM creates articulation challenges for older or less musically experienced singers

The melody is anthemic and memorable, with a driving rhythm that energizes younger and contemporary worship settings. However, the D5 ceiling in the original key is high for mixed congregations, particularly men singing melody and older adults. Dropping to C major brings the ceiling to C5, which is more sustainable. The rapid lyric delivery at 130 BPM requires clear diction and familiarity with the text - this is not a song that congregations can sight-sing easily on first encounter. The repetitive chorus structure aids memorization, but the verses pack significant theological content into short melodic phrases, which can feel rushed.

04Poetic and lyrical quality
8.9
The creed-based lyrics prioritize doctrinal precision over poetic imagery, and the rapid-fire delivery can feel mechanical, but the corporate voice and theological weight compensate

The song's poetic strength lies in its confessional structure and corporate voice, not in metaphor or imagery. The repeated 'we believe' functions as liturgical refrain, reinforcing unity and shared conviction. The lyrics are lean and declarative, avoiding embellishment in favor of clarity. This is intentional - the song is doing the work of a creed, not a hymn of adoration. The lack of first-person singular voice is a strength here, as corporate confession is the mode. The rhythm and rhyme scheme are functional rather than artful, but the theological architecture is impressive.

05Defense brief
9.5

The song's creed-based structure and orthodox content make it highly defensible theologically. Potential objections center on stylistic preference, the rapid tempo's impact on congregational comprehension, and whether a pop-rock arrangement suits the gravitas of doctrinal confession. These are secondary concerns that do not undermine the song's theological integrity. The song's greatest apologetic strength is its function as catechesis - it teaches the faith while the church sings.

How scores are calculated →

Full analysis

This song stands as a modern expression of the Apostles' Creed, translating the historic confession of the church into a congregational anthem with energy and clarity. The theological architecture is comprehensive, moving systematically through the Trinity and the economy of salvation: the Father as Creator, the Son's incarnation and redemptive work, and the Spirit's ongoing sanctification. Each article of faith is grounded in Scripture, and the corporate 'we believe' voice positions the congregation as the confessing body, not isolated individuals. This is catechetical worship at its best, teaching doctrine while the church sings.

The song's greatest strength is its doctrinal precision and scope. It affirms the virgin birth, the substitutionary nature of Christ's death, the bodily resurrection, the ascension, and the promised return. It confesses the Spirit's role in making believers holy and calls the church to live in light of eschatological hope. This is not vague spirituality or therapeutic religion - it is the faith once delivered to the saints, sung with conviction. The creed structure ensures that no essential element of the gospel is omitted or minimized.

The primary challenges are practical rather than theological. The original key pushes most congregations at the upper range, and the tempo creates lyric density that can feel rushed. Worshipers accustomed to slower, more reflective songs may find the pace disorienting. However, these concerns are mitigated by adjusting the key to C major and considering a slightly slower tempo (115-120 BPM) to allow the words to land. The song benefits from strong vocal leadership and clear lyric projection, and it should be used in contexts where the congregation has some familiarity with creedal language.

For Baptist worship leaders in the BGCT tradition, this song offers a powerful tool for reinforcing core doctrine in a culturally accessible form. It pairs well with teaching moments, baptismal services, and affirmation of faith. The absence of sacramental language and the emphasis on personal faith and sanctification align with Baptist theology, while the Trinitarian structure honors historic orthodoxy. Use this song to anchor the congregation in the faith, but balance it with songs that express personal devotion, lament, or adoration to create a well-rounded worship experience.

Defense brief

"The song feels more like a theological checklist than worship - it's too propositional and lacks emotional warmth or personal devotion."
Liturgical

Who raises this: Worshipers accustomed to affective, first-person singular songs; those who prioritize relational intimacy in worship language

Scripture response

The Psalms themselves contain both affective praise and declarative confession (Psalm 100, 103, 136). The corporate 'we believe' echoes Israel's Shema (Deuteronomy 6:4) and the early church's creedal confessions. Romans 10:9 links confession of belief with salvation. Corporate doctrinal declaration is a biblical worship mode.

Suggested framing

This song functions as a sung creed, similar to how many traditions recite the Apostles' Creed. It is not meant to replace songs of adoration or lament, but to anchor the congregation in shared theological conviction. Pair it with more affective songs to create a balanced worship arc.

Honest concession
This song does prioritize doctrine over emotion, and some worshipers will find it intellectually dense. It works best in contexts where the congregation values theological precision and is comfortable with creedal language.
"The tempo and lyric density make it hard to sing thoughtfully - we end up racing through the creed without meditating on what we're confessing."
Musical

Who raises this: Musicians, contemplative worshipers, older congregants, those who value slower, reflective worship

Scripture response

Psalm 46:10 calls for stillness and knowing God. The concern is valid - rapid delivery can obscure meaning. However, other psalms celebrate energetic praise (Psalm 149, 150). The issue is not the song itself, but how it is used in the service flow.

Suggested framing

Acknowledge the tempo and use the song strategically. Consider slowing it down slightly (to 120 BPM) or pausing between sections to let the doctrine settle. Alternatively, use it as a corporate declaration after a sermon or teaching moment when the congregation has already engaged the content reflectively.

Honest concession
The original tempo is optimized for recording and performance, not necessarily congregational comprehension. Slower delivery or strategic placement in the service can mitigate this concern.
"The pop-rock style feels too casual for the weight of the creed - should we be confessing the faith to a drumbeat that sounds like a stadium anthem?"
Cultural

Who raises this: Traditional worshipers, those who associate certain musical styles with reverence and others with entertainment

Scripture response

Psalm 150 calls for worship with loud cymbals, strings, and dancing. Scripture does not prescribe musical style, only that worship be offered in spirit and truth (John 4:24). The early church adapted the musical forms of its culture. The question is whether the style serves the content, not whether the style matches a particular tradition's preferences.

Suggested framing

Musical style is a matter of cultural context, not theological validity. This song brings the ancient creed into a contemporary musical language that connects with many worshipers, particularly younger generations. The energy of the arrangement reflects the joy and confidence of the resurrection faith being confessed.

Honest concession
The pop-rock style will not resonate with all congregations, particularly those shaped by traditional hymnody or classical liturgy. Worship leaders should know their congregation's musical culture and choose accordingly.

Scripture map

Primary foundations

1 Corinthians 15:3-8The song's confession of Christ's death, burial, resurrection, and appearances echoes Paul's summary of the gospel, which he received and passed on as of first importance.
John 3:16The declaration of belief in God the Father and His only Son Jesus Christ directly reflects the Johannine testimony to God's love and the unique sonship of Christ.
Luke 1:35The affirmation of Christ's birth by the Holy Spirit and the virgin Mary is drawn from the angelic announcement to Mary, grounding the incarnation in Gospel narrative.
Acts 1:9-11The song's expectation of Christ's return as coming King mirrors the angelic promise at the ascension that Jesus will return in the same way He departed.

Supporting connections

Genesis 1:1The confession of God the Father as Creator of heaven and earth echoes the opening declaration of Scripture.
Romans 8:11The Spirit's work in sanctification and the resurrection hope are central to Paul's teaching on the Spirit's role in the believer's life.
Revelation 19:11-16The imagery of Christ as coming King aligns with John's vision of the returning Messiah as conquering ruler.
Ephesians 4:4-6The Trinitarian structure and emphasis on corporate unity in faith reflect Paul's teaching on one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all.

Story behind the song

The song was written by Matthew Hooper, Richie Fike, and Travis Ryan for the Newsboys' 2017 album 'United.' The writers intentionally crafted a creed-based song to provide congregations with a doctrinally rich anthem that teaches the core tenets of the Christian faith.

Album liner notes, United (Newsboys)

The song emerged during a period when many worship leaders were seeking theologically substantive songs that could function as both corporate confession and catechesis. The Newsboys, known for their energetic pop-rock sound, adapted the Apostles' Creed into a form that would resonate with contemporary worship settings.

Worship leader discussions and CCLI usage reports

The song quickly gained traction in evangelical and Baptist churches, particularly among congregations that value doctrinal clarity and wanted a modern alternative to reciting the creed. Its use in worship has reinforced the connection between historic Christian confession and contemporary musical expression.

CCLI reporting and worship ministry feedback

Hymn lineage

{"teaching_note":"Introducing the congregation to the Apostles' Creed alongside this song can deepen understanding of the faith they are confessing and connect them to the historic church. Consider reciting the creed before or after singing the song.","connection_note":"This song is a contemporary musical setting of the Apostles' Creed, one of the oldest and most widely used statements of Christian faith. The creed's structure and content are directly reflected in the song's lyrics, making it a modern expression of an ancient confession.","historical_author":"Ancient Church (traditional)","historical_hymn_title":"Apostles' Creed","consider_teaching_both":true}

Themes

TrinityCreationIncarnationAtonementResurrectionAscensionSecond ComingSanctificationEschatologyCorporate ConfessionCreed

Sermon series fit

The Apostles' CreedFoundational DoctrinesWho is Jesus?The Work of the Holy SpiritThe Hope of ResurrectionWhat We BelieveThe Story of Salvation

Audience fit

Maturity

Most effective with congregants who have some familiarity with creedal language and orthodox theology. Can serve as teaching tool for newer believers if contextualized.

Age group

Broad appeal, particularly strong with youth, young adults, and contemporary worship settings. The energy and tempo may be less accessible to older traditional congregants.

Service type

Contemporary worship, blended services, youth gatherings, baptismal services, and services emphasizing corporate confession or doctrinal teaching.

Visitor-friendly

Moderately visitor-friendly. The creed structure is clear and the content is accessible, but the tempo and theological density may require familiarity. Best used when the congregation can join confidently.

Special contexts

Excellent for baptismal services, membership classes, affirmation of faith moments, and sermon series on core doctrine. Also effective in youth camps and retreats where catechesis is a priority.

Similar songs

If you love this song

This I Believe (The Creed) - Hillsong Worship

If this concerns you

In Christ Alone - Keith Getty & Stuart Townend (slower, more reflective creed-based song)

Great Is Thy Faithfulness - Thomas Chisholm (classic hymn with doctrinal content)

How Deep the Father's Love for Us - Stuart Townend (contemplative, theologically rich)

Related songs

This I Believe (The Creed)

Ben Fielding, Matt Crocker

9.4

I Believe

Chris Davenport, Jonathan Smith, Phil Wickham

9.2

Lord I Lift Your Name On High

Rick Founds

9.3

New Doxology

Louis Bourgeois, Thomas Ken, Thomas Miller

9.6

There Is A Redeemer

Melody Green

9.3